Side-by-side crime statistics from official UK Police data.
S70 · Barnsley
458
crimes in April 2026
Above national average
S60 · Rotherham
168
crimes in April 2026
Near national average
Rotherham has less crime — 168 vs 458 incidents in April 2026.
Barnsley recorded substantially more crime than Rotherham in April 2026 — 458 incidents compared to 168, a 2.7x difference. The crime profiles diverge meaningfully: Barnsley sees higher rates of Criminal damage & arson (42), while Rotherham has more Shoplifting (27). Both areas sit near the national average, with modest differences in their overall safety profile.
Full reports cover 24 months of trends, ward breakdowns, outcome rates, and a detailed safety score — from £4.99.
Based on April 2026 Police data, Rotherham recorded fewer crimes than Barnsley — 168 vs 458 incidents. That is 63% fewer crimes. Barnsley is above the national average.
The main difference lies in crime type. In April 2026, Barnsley saw higher rates of Criminal damage & arson while Rotherham had more Shoplifting. Overall, Rotherham recorded fewer total crimes (168 vs 458).